• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Foliovision

Making the web work for you

Main navigation

  • Weblog
    • FV Player
    • WordPress
    • Video of the Week
    • Case Studies
    • Business
  • About
    • Testimonials
    • Meet the Team
    • We Support
    • Careers
    • Contact
    • Pricing
  • Products
  • Support
    • FV Player Docs
    • Pro Support
  • Login
  • Basket is empty
Affordable VAST/VPAID for Wordpress has arrived. Serve ads with your videos starting today!

The Ups and Downs of Using YouTube’s Auto-captions

29 January 2018 / Eduard / Leave a Comment

Adding subtitles to your videos is always a great idea. They can let the viewers watch it without sound (which is important for the silent autoplay, that is making it's way to the new versions of iOS and Android), make it easier to understand what has been said if the audio is too noisy or lower quality, and help non-native speakers better understand the spoken word. It's also necessary for people with hearing impairment.

YouTube understands that and they encourage the content creators to add subtitles to their videos. They offer a great way to easily create transcripts, which is usually a time-consuming process, or requires a specific and expensive software. It offers two options: creating an automatic transcript and putting in your own text and have it synced automatically with the video.

Auto-failtitles

The first option is the one you probably know very well. YouTube can generate the text of the subtitles from the audio track of a video. The service is far from perfect, but it's free, fast and easy to use. The best way to describe it is "better than nothing". Take a look at these two extracts from subtitles from this YouTube video - Top 10 Ways To Take Your Mountain Bike To The Next Level:

  • This is part of the manually entered subtitles
    1
    00:00:00,010 --> 00:00:04,168
    - [Neil] So here's our Top 10 ways of
    really taking your bike to the next level
    
    2
    00:00:04,168 --> 00:00:06,878
    so it's as cool as a pro bike.
    
    3
    00:00:06,878 --> 00:00:09,813
    Sort out your cables.
    Cables should be just
  • This is the same part, only from the auto-generated subtitles
    1
    00:00:00,120 --> 00:00:02,520
    so here's our top ten ways of really
    
    2
    00:00:02,520 --> 00:00:04,440
    taking your bite to the next level so
    
    3
    00:00:04,440 --> 00:00:07,109
    it's as cool as a pro bite sawed 80
    
    4
    00:00:07,109 --> 00:00:09,840
    cables cables should be just

As you can see, the software recognized the word "bike" as "bite" and "sort out your" came out as "sawed 80". This is partially given by Neil's cool British accent, but the longer the video is, the more fails like this you will encounter.

YouTube auto-generated subtitles are far from perfect

Fixing the damaged captions

As you can see in the example above, the auto-generated transcript is usually just a good placeholder. The best way is of course creating the subtitles manually.

There are plenty of ways of doing this, including using another YouTube's tool, that is described in detail in our article How to create video subtitles using Youtube. That can, however, be only used when you uploaded the video yourself.

But what if you want to use a video uploaded by another user and still want to create quality subtitles?

There are couple of tools that can help you to download the auto-generated subtitle track. Our favourite is DIYCaptions. It's a free online tool in which you put the URL of the video and the software will immediately load the auto-generated track (if available) into it's editing interface and let you edit the text line-by-line, thus allowing you to correct all the inevitable errors. 

DIYCaptions
DIYCaptions editing interface

The interface works in a similar way as our Interactive Transcript - the text is shown in full and clicking on a single line will make the video playback jump to the point where the line starts, so you can check with audio if the transcription is correct and fix it if necessary.

The software can then export the files in .txt and .srt formats, which is great, as FV Player supports .srt. The only downside is, that when a YouTube video has other subtitles, the software will load those, like in the example above.

How to use it with FV Player

As said, FV Player supports the SRT format along with WebVTT, so the workflow you could possibly use and we recommend is to not rely on the auto-generated transcript and instead edit it to a usable text with DIYCaptions. The text then can be exported and used as regular subtitles. Using subtitles in FV Player is explained in more detail in this guide - How to Create Subtitles.

Share4
Tweet
Share
4 Shares

Categories: Flowplayer

Related Posts

  1. FV Player’s New Feature: Interactive Video Transcript

  2. FV Player’s New Features: YouTube Subtitles and Fixed Error Reporting in Chrome

  3. Interactive Video Transcript

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You can click here to Subscribe without commenting

Primary Sidebar

Categories

  • Business
  • Cameras
  • Case Studies
  • Design
  • Flowplayer
  • Internet Marketing
  • IT
  • Life
  • SEO
  • Slovak
  • Video of the Week
  • WordPress

Footer

Our Plugins

  • FV WordPress Flowplayer
  • FV Thoughtful Comments
  • FV Simpler SEO
  • FV Antispam
  • FV Gravatar Cache
  • FV Testimonials

Free Tools

  • Pandoc Online
  • Article spinner
  • WordPress Password Finder
  • Delete LinkedIn Account
  • Responsive Design Calculator
Foliovision logo
All materials © 2021 Foliovision s.r.o. | Panská 12 - 81101 Bratislava - Slovakia | info@foliovision.com
  • This Site Uses Cookies
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Site Map
  • Contact
  • Tel. +1 518 412 4600